Mary Sheffer

Mary Sheffer

Administration Supervisor

Mary joined the McConkey team in August 2019 as Administrative Coordinator, and was promoted to Administration Supervisor in September 2021. She came to us with over 17 years of administrative experience, most recently as Financial Administrator/Treasurer at Yorkshire United Methodist Church in York. Though she also has experience in the fields of accounting and real estate, this is her first job within the insurance industry!

Born and raised in York, Mary still lives here with her husband, Keith. Together they have a son and two daughters, as well as a miniature cockapoo named Barkley.

In addition to her full time job at McConkey, Mary has served as a dance instructor for about 30 years. She currently teaches for Innovations Dance Center. She also enjoys walking and getting to the beach as frequently as possible.

Fun Fact: Mary and her husband, Keith, met on a blind date in 1991 and have been together ever since!